A vocal contingent of prominent doctors and scientists is pressing the Biden administration to scrap its plans to provide booster shots to all previously vaccinated adults, according to five people familiar with the matter.
Several of these outside experts, including some who advised President Joe Biden’s transition team, objected to the administration’s approach during a private, off-the-record call last week with federal health officials. Current U.S. data on vaccine performance does not justify using boosters widely to reduce the risk of breakthrough infections and slow the virus’ spread, the experts said.
They told officials on the Sept. 27 call — including Biden’s chief medical adviser, Anthony Fauci; White House policy adviser Cameron Webb; and the heads of the Food and Drug Administration and Centers for Disease Control and Prevention — that the shots should be given to people most at risk of severe Covid-19 to reduce hospitalizations and deaths.
The growing split between Biden’s team and outside health experts on boosters threatens to disrupt a key source of support the administration has relied on to sell its vaccination drive to the American public. Biden, who took office pledging to “follow the science,” until recently enjoyed the enthusiastic backing of eminent physicians and researchers as he attempted to crush Covid-19 and revive the U.S. economy. But the White House’s sweeping vision for boosters has weakened those ties.
Now, even some experts who support the president’s broad booster strategy say the White House has fumbled its messaging on the topic, confusing the public as Biden’s team tries to limit new surges of infection through the winter.
“It undermines credibility not just for [federal health]agencies but for the administration overall,” said Irwin Redlener, director of the Pandemic Resource and Response Initiative at Columbia University. “Somebody needs a communication lesson. Maybe many people do.”
The White House did not respond to a request for comment. A spokesperson for the Department of Health and Human Services said the administration “regularly engage[s] outside stakeholders from the medical community with a broad array of viewpoints for their feedback” on the administration’s pandemic policies.
“We are doing all we can to offer Americans the maximum protection afforded by vaccines, including constantly working to increase the number of primary vaccinations as well as ensuring boosters are available to all who are eligible,” the spokesperson said.
The White House has held regular off-the-record calls with health experts since Biden took office, often to preview major announcements or push its talking points, three of the people familiar with the discussions said. They are typically led by Surgeon General Vivek Murthy and other senior administration officials, including Fauci, CDC Director Rochelle Walensky and acting FDA Commissioner Janet Woodcock. Dozens of prominent scientists and physicians have participated.
Now, with the FDA preparing to authorize boosters from Moderna and Johnson & Johnson, top federal health officials have reached out to administration surrogates to promote the government’s approach. Biden’s team is stressing the importance of using boosters to prevent breakthrough infections, even mild cases.
The discussions have taken place amid ongoing tensions between scientists at the CDC and FDA and other federal officials working on the Covid-19 response about the administration’s public messaging on vaccine efficacy and boosters, given the gaps in available data.
The Sept. 27 call was originally planned for the week before. The White House abruptly rescheduled it after the CDC’s independent vaccine advisory committee recommended that the Pfizer-BioNTech booster be reserved for high-risk groups, including the elderly.
The rescheduled call was the tensest one to date, according to the three people with information on the talks. Fauci argued that the CDC committee’s stance — that science did not support giving boosters to all adults — was incorrect. And he dismissed suggestions that the administration had to choose between a broad U.S. booster campaign and donating vaccines to countries in need.
The president’s chief medical adviser also told the outside experts that boosters could, and should, be given widely to reduce the spread of the coronavirus rather than only to prevent severe disease or death.
Fauci’s remarks drew disagreement on the call, the five people familiar with the matter said. Several participants were left mystified about the goal of the government’s vaccination campaign.
“It was very tense,” one person said. “More than anything, it was like Fauci felt he needed to make a point.”
Since the FDA and CDC authorized limited use of the Pfizer-BioNTech booster in late September, top administration health officials have said publicly that they will follow the recommendations of scientists in planning the booster rollout.
But hours after the Pfizer-BioNTech decision, Biden predicted that booster shots would soon be available “across the board.”
“In the near term, we’re probably going to open this up,” the president said.
Fauci, Walensky and other leaders of the administration’s Covid-19 response have also publicly questioned the FDA and CDC’s decisions to restrict the Pfizer-BioNTech booster to the elderly and younger people at high risk by virtue of their jobs or underlying health status.
The dichotomy between the Biden team’s boosters-for-all philosophy and the targeted use endorsed by the health agencies and their independent advisory panels has frustrated some of the nation’s leading doctors.
Many — including Céline Gounder, an infectious diseases specialist at Bellevue Hospital in New York City who served on the Biden transition’s Covid-19 advisory board, and Megan Ranney, an emergency room doctor and associate dean at the School of Public Health at Brown University — argue that the U.S. should focus on convincing holdouts at home to get their initial shots and on shipping more doses overseas to reduce the risk that new and dangerous virus variants will emerge. Craig Spencer, the director of Global Health in Emergency Medicine at Columbia University Medical Center, has also publicly pushed back against the administration’s thinking on boosters.
“There is some benefit to reducing transmission with boosters. But that benefit is marginal compared to the benefit of vaccinating people in parts of the country that are not vaccinated, never gotten a dose to begin with,” said Nahid Bhadelia, director of Boston University’s Center for Emerging Infectious Diseases Policy and Research. “Even with the booster, the antibodies may go down again. And as long as there is a pool of people who are not vaccinated in the community, I’m not going to be 100 percent protected.”
Bhadelia stressed that she believes all Americans will eventually need boosters, but that the U.S. should wait to expand eligibility until the data supports that.
Others say that with the pandemic closing in on its third year and no end in sight, the administration must make tough decisions on boosters without full data.
Biden Vaccine Mandate for Contractors Blocked Nationwide
- Mandate one of a set of Biden vaccine initiatives
- States say contractor requirement violates Constitution
The Biden administration’s mandate for federal contractors’ employees to be vaccinated will be halted nationwide, amid a slew of challenges from states that say the president overstepped his authority in requiring the Covid-19 shots.
Led by Georgia, the seven states that challenged the mandate set to take effect on Jan. 4 are likely to succeed in their lawsuits against the administration’s order, U.S. District Court Judge R. Stan Baker of the Southern District of Georgia said in an order issued Tuesday.
The Biden administration mandate applies to roughly a quarter of the U.S. workforce and affects companies that do business with the federal government, including Lockheed Martin Corp., Microsoft Corp., Alphabet Inc.‘s Google, and General Motors Co.
Baker’s order follows a Kentucky federal judge’s grant last week of a preliminary injunction in a lawsuit involving Kentucky, Tennessee, and Ohio. Baker echoed what his Kentucky counterpart said, that blocking the mandate didn’t indicate that the vaccine wouldn’t be effective to stopping the spread of Covid-19, but rather that Biden didn’t have the power to issue such an executive order.
Representatives from Georgia universities testified during an injunction hearing earlier this month, arguing that implementation of the mandate would be expensive, onerous, and cost them valuable employees who haven’t yet presented proof of vaccination. Those schools receive millions from the federal government.
The court found that the states could likely prove that Congress didn’t clearly authorize the president to issue the mandate, and that it “goes far beyond addressing administrative and management issues in order to promote efficiency and economy in procurement and contracting.” The 2017 nominee of President Donald Trump said, instead, the executive order works as a “regulation of public health.”
Neither the lawyers representing the state coalition nor the U.S. government immediately responded to emailed requests for comment.
Idaho Gov. Brad Little cheered Tuesday’s ruling in a statement. The state is part of the Georgia-led contractor mandate challenge, as well as lawsuits against the Occupational Safety and Hazard Administration’s shot-or-test emergency regulation for large U.S. businesses, and another inoculation rule for healthcare workers.
“Yet another one of President Biden’s vaccine mandates have been temporarily shut down because the states—including Idaho—took a stand against his unprecedented government overreach into Americans’ lives and businesses,” Little said in the statement. “All three mandates are now completely stalled. We will continue to press forward in our fight against the federal government’s bad policies.”
Men and Boys aged 12 to 29 should no longer take Moderna Vaccine, Says National Advisory Committee on Immunization in Canada
Luxemburg: People break down barriers of Covid pass checkpoint at Christmas Market
Health7 days ago
Israel admits almost all Covid infections and deaths are vaccinated. They acknowledge the 3rd shot caused “immuno erosion”
Health2 weeks ago
108 FIFA players & coaches have died in the last 6 months alone
Health1 week ago
Bill Gates has been officially been charged with murder over vaccines in India
Health2 weeks ago
Ivermectin Ends Covid in Japan
Health2 weeks ago
Wikipedia Stops Listing Athletes who Died While Playing Soccer as the Number Explodes
Entertainment4 weeks ago
Something Extremely Dark Happened at Travis Scott’s Deadly “Astroworld” Festival
US News2 weeks ago
CNN lightens skin color of Waukesha BLM-supporting Christmas parade killer
Health2 weeks ago
Africa is only 6% vaccinated, and covid has practically disappeared… scientists “baffled”